Thursday, 18. September 2014
26. 10. 12. - 15:00
Article 1325 of the Austrian Civil Code allows the possibility to claim compensation for physical and emotional suffering.
It is a valid offer, as emotional distress can often seem far more cruel than any physical pain, especially if the suffering was at the hands of those who are closest - namely family.
But in one of those curious anomalies that is the legal system in practice this is not always as straightforward as it seems.
Take for example the case of one woman who told the Austrian Supreme Court she was suffering from insomnia, headaches, anxiety attacks and depression and psychosis as a result of her husband's adultery.
Experts testified that her emotional suffering and even the sudden onset of skin cancer were caused by the adulterous behaviour of her husband.
But the court threw out the case - ruling that a spouse cannot claim compensation for emotional suffering against their partner if it is caused by the adultery.
The reason is that the court views marriage as a dissolvable relationship - meaning the injured party was only entitled to claim back the expenses in exposing that affair, for example though the hiring of a detective.
However the relationship between a parent and child is not viewed by the courts as dissolvable, but rather as permanent. That means that in contrast to the marriage where it is possible to "dissolve" the suffering through divorce / separation, the parent-child relationship is permanent and therefore the suffering cannot be dissolved.
Therefore compensation for emotional suffering could be due if one parent denies the contact of the other parent to the child, without good reason.
That is now being tested in a case here in Austria in which a father suffered from a diagnosable mental illness because the other parent influenced the child negatively in encouraging them to severe ties with their father.
In the pending lawsuit the dad claimed compensation for emotional suffering because the mother denied him contact to the child. An expert opinion confirmed that the father suffered from a diagnosable mental illness because the mother blocked him from seeing his child.
The judgement will be passed soon.
Austrian Times columnist Matthias Loinig is a legal correspondent and campaigner for more transparency and fairness in family law in Austria. One of the main areas he specialises in is the often obscure decisions by courts of custody - in particular over the tendency to favour the mother at the cost of the father. He is now a veteran campaigner with extensive experience of the justice system and works with a team of legal professionals recognised as the most experienced and skilled family law practitioners in Austria. He has worked towards resolutions for many parents and children, especially in cases where the parents have an immigration background, and is now a columnist for the Austrian Times Group.
Pat On The Back From Manure Explosive
A traffic cop in Austria got more than he bargained for after a booby trap covered him head-to-toe in manure as he was trying to catch people speeding.
Viennese Jihad Girl May Have Been Killed
Austrian police say that one of the two attractive young teenage girls who fled the country to go to Syria to fight on the side of Islamic rebels may have been killed.
Perversion of a Medical Dream
The Decline and Fall of the Otto Wagner Hospital, Vienna.
Fat Can Be Used To Burn Off Weight After New Patent Unveiled
It is being hailed as a sensation after scientists at an Austrian university patented a method that transforms fat storing cells into mini factories capable of actually destroying fat by burning it off.
Three Family Members Dead In Well Tragedy
A mother has lost her husband, her pregnant daughter and her son-in-law after a tragic accident where one of them fell into a well and the other two died while trying to carry out a failed rescue.
Brit Soldier Rescued After Climbing Mountain In T Shirt
A British soldier who tackled the frozen Austrian Alps wearing just shorts and a T-shirt has been rapped by officials after he had to be rescued from the snowy peak.
Mum And Daughter Struck By Lightning In Pool
A mother and her daughter were hospitalised after they were struck by lightning – in a swimming pool.
Police Nab Porn Star Who Filmed In Local Church
A woman accused of making a porn movie in a local church has been caught after an informant tipped off police that he recognised her by her breasts after an appeal for information.
Young Hip Hop Dancer Gets 18 Years For Drug Smuggling
A blonde hip hop dancer and charity worker promised an international career after she was spotted by a talent scout has been jailed for 18 years in Indonesia after her work offer turned out to have been part of an elaborate drugs con.
Teen Dying Of Cancer Killed At Charity Event After Ride In Porsche Goes Wrong
The family of a sick boy who was offered a trip in a high-performance Porsche because he was dying of cancer is suing the charity after the Porsche he was travelling in crashed head-on into oncoming traffic.
The most popular stories –
last 7 days
|Sex Pest Simulator Developed For Japanese Gropers|
|Pair Caught in Early Morning Underground Sex Video|
|Viennese Jihad Girl May Have Been Killed|
|Toy Story Is A Tall One|
|Bloody Mass As Knifeman Chops Up Love Rival|
Why suffer in silence. Let off steam by letting our readers share your troubles. File your complaints about anything and everything here.
Our ombudsman David Rogers will try and help solve some of the problems from lazy civil servants through to incompetent companies – and at the very least the worst transgressors will end up in our weekly special report.